
Links go to search results. Availability varies by region.
総合タワーリシチ
13
3
Finished
Aug 11, 2011 to May 22, 2013
6.0/10
Average Review Score
33%
Recommend It
3
Reviews Worldwide
I kind of like this and at the same time i feel disappointed by it the more i think of it. I was thinking it would be about the two MC's relationship. But for about half the chapters we are given interactions between a group of other students. When we just have the Two MC's spending time together it's actually really adorable and funny. But we spend are time with a group of characters that aren't that interesting except the one smart one of the group. There's also a new character that comes in and she's pretty good. But if we had the story justfocused on are two MC's this would've been a much better story in my opinion. They are both smart. One is a shy quite type while the other is a energetic one. There's also some side stories that just feel like they left them without completing. The art is pretty good though. I do love that the characters get together in the end. Kind of wish it showed more of them together.
Kanna who usually enjoys being at the top of her class is outscored by one point on the first aptitude test of her high school career by the high-level kuudere/low-level dandere Yuu. Unlike Kanna, Yuu is naturally talented and couldn't care less about getting high scores, so she throws away her test immediately after after getting it. This incredibly bothers Kanna, who then in front of the class, scolds Yuu for throwing away her "symbol of how hard she worked". This gesture of kindness(??) causes Yuu to fall for Kanna. And of course, all unbeknownst to Kanna, who's all about herself anyway. (Source: MU)
All you need to read is a few chapters and you can distinctly tell that this is an Iri Arata story because Arata sure loves their side characters. Tovarisch is Russian for comrade, friend, companion and so on and so forth; adding “Comprehensive” in front of that certainly makes for an interesting title. The series is pretty comprehensive when it comes to the different types of characters that are around but the relationships themselves are also quite comprehensive. To sum that up, the pairings are 100% legitimate. Yuu Hazaoka and Kanna Kirigami are the stars of the series and with good reason, they’re interesting, lovableand steal the show whenever they’re the focus. Unfortunately, the series suffers precisely from lacking that focus. Don’t get me wrong, I can see why Arata wanted to flesh out the rest of their cast of characters but the main issue is the fact that the series has only 13 listed chapters. The other characters receive the focus in the short chapters called “Break Time” and there’s 10 total of those (not including the 4-koma one), so while they technically don’t take away screentime from Yuu and Kanna, they make up just as much of the series as the main story. The characters themselves are colorful and it’s quite easy to see why they’d be polarizing; I could live with the “four stooges” that got most of the “Break Time” spotlight but I didn’t care for most of the student council that was introduced later. So if you find the other characters annoying or unlikable then it’s understandable why this series wouldn’t be very appealing to you. Full credit to Arata though, this series is most definitely not yuri bait. It feels like the bare minimum to praise something like this but those who’ve been hurt before know the pain of a good pairing that finishes with subtext (at most). The pacing towards an actual defined Yuu x Kanna relationship might not have been as great as it could’ve been but the fact that it gets there is definitely satisfying - and the extras after chapter 13 that feature them directly contribute to that. Not to mention that the other characters get their own cute moments with their respective partners. Overall, these relationships are the main draw of the story. This is a series I wanted to love because Yuu and Kanna are seriously such a nice pairing but every time I revisit it I can only come to the conclusion that I liked it. It is truly a shame that the end of Tsubomi, the magazine in which this series was serialized in, caused the series to also end as I do think it had the potential to be a very enjoyable story. The artstyle is cute, I’m partial to Yuu as a whole, and I like Kanna’s energy so I ended up giving this a 7.5/10. I’ve completed 2 rereads of this and I’m sure I’ll come back to it again even though I don’t think it’s anything too special.
I think this manga starts off pretty strong but after a few chapters it entirely drops the main pairing for the shenanigans of the ensemble cast. The chapters after the shift in focus are difficult to follow, there's a lot of text and chaos on the page which is primarily dedicated to bits and buries the story in clutter. The balance between bits and things actually happening gradually gets worse over time and when the main pairing is picked up again it's pretty jarring. The story concludes immediately after, so even though I did like the characters in the early chapters its pretty unsatisfying tosuddenly snap back to the romance after all of the confusion of the second half. Despite that the side pairings are just enough to keep it readable and its genuinely really funny, so there are some highs to temper the disappointment, but I wish that everything had been integrated better. Short enough to sort of recommend as an afternoon read if you're not looking for anything really impactful.