
Links go to search results. Availability varies by region.
痣だらけのクラスメイト
Ongoing
1
Finished
Mar 27, 2024
6.3/10
Average Review Score
25%
Recommend It
4
Reviews Worldwide
Nah this just wasn't it. Lets talk about things other than story, then firstly its the layout, and its the usual web manga 1-2 pages per chapter. I have always disliked that format because it often results in weird pacing, where its just easy to assume to have read a certain amount of chapters but actually the content is not worth any more than a chapter or two in the normal format. This one is not anymore than 2 chapters in a weekly manga, so naturally the pacing is also incredibly fast. It is an episodic manga written in a way that the main character issupposed to be you, somewhat of a first person POV manga, if that exists. Also most of the dialogues are just her repeating phrases which were said by the mc. Art is good. While you will only see the girl for most of the manga, her design is decent and the little details on her makes it much more visually appealing. I liked the thing they did with dialogue boxes, changed its colours, depending on how much she is opening up to the mc. Backgrounds are kinda basic looking for the most part where they are not needed, but at times where they do play a part to convey something, they are drawn well. Now about the story and you know it has a premise which is sure to generate curiosity, kind of a cheap and easy method, but hey, it works most of the times. But the author approached the starting of the story in a way which made it look a whole lot different than what he would have expected. The main character came off as exploiting the girl considering her an easy one. Surely a mismatch between author's thinking and its implementation. But that first impression helped setting up a thought process which ended up impacting the enjoyment for a decent chunk of the starting. My curiosity got the best of me, and I accidently ended up reading a not so flattering hentai of this, produced by the author himself, which further diminished my enjoyment. Anyway talking about the overall storyline, if you just looked it up from afar, very linear. It thrives from the sympathy of the readers (I mean you have to be kidding me if you didn't root for her recovery) and rewards them with a wholesome gift at the end. Story development isn't much focused on. The ending was all too visible the moment I read the first page, so there wasn't much room for other shenanigans. A bit conflicted whether to give it 5 or 6, but I am leaning more towards a 6, considering I did root for the girl and enjoyed it a bit.
A story from the perspective of a concerned protagonist and a female classmate who's suspiciously covered in bruises.
A fairly simple “nice guy troubled girl” story kept fresh through its gimmick. The key to its effectiveness is two simple tools: consistent POV and black-and-white speech bubbles. What it’s able to pull off with that same vibe of her “talking to you” coupled by her words being cleansed like soot makes it almost feel like a VN with no batteries required. It makes the few points where it deviates from this format work as good jumpscares. If you go into this with that in mind, it’s worth a shot. The ending is pretty sweet too. For something more detailed in this vein, try Zyugoya’s “When IReturned to My Hometown, My Childhood Friend Was Broken“
Azadarake no Classmate’s story consists of a few pages per chapter about an abused girl's life from the eyes of a self inset main character that has no visual presence. All of the chapters are focussed on the abused main character as she quotes verbatim what the male lead would have said if he had been shown or had a voice. If it's not the aforementioned it's showing the various forms of abuse she receives at home before returning to school or other locations to have a chat with the male lead. It was recommended to me as a wholesome story despite the abuse but thatcouldn't be further from reality. If you're arriving from a similar recommendation I suggest finding an alternative.
This is less than 200 pages in total. It uses the format of tsuntsuntsun with most pages being the girl answering back, which is horrible format to tell a story. If this had been made into an actual manga, either a slow burner like Oyasumi Punpun or a blazing dumpster fire like Henshin/Emergence/Metamorphosis/177013, then I would easily have given it an 8/10 or even higher. The story itself dives into the struggles of not knowing how to help a struggling classmate that is clearling getting roughed up at home. The hopelessness of not understanding how the world of grown ups functions and the confusion asto why no adult can see the child needs help.